CAPE Ratio

The Cyclically Adjusted Price-to-Earnings (CAPE) ratio, also known as the Shiller P/E ratio or P/E 10, is a popular financial metric developed by renowned economist Robert Shiller. It is employed to evaluate whether a stock market is overvalued or undervalued by comparing its current price to its average earnings over the past 10 years, adjusted for inflation.

Origin and Development

Robert Shiller, along with John Campbell, introduced the concept of the CAPE ratio in a seminal paper published in 1988. The primary motivation behind CAPE was to provide a more stable and reliable valuation metric by smoothing out short-term fluctuations in a company’s earnings which could be influenced by business cycles, economic downturns, or other transient factors.

Calculation

The CAPE ratio is calculated using the following formula:

[ \text{CAPE Ratio} = \frac{\text{Current Price of the S&P 500 Index}}{\text{average real earnings of the S&P 500 companies over the past 10 years}} ]

Here, “real earnings” refer to earnings adjusted for inflation, typically using the Consumer Price Index (CPI).

Steps to Calculate CAPE Ratio

  1. Collect Data: Obtain the historical earnings data of the companies in the market index (commonly the S&P 500) for at least the past 10 years.

  2. Inflation Adjustment: Adjust these earnings figures for inflation to reflect their real value. This is typically done using the CPI.

  3. Average Calculation: Compute the average of the yearly inflation-adjusted earnings over the 10-year period.

  4. Current Price: Obtain the current price level of the market index.

  5. Compute Ratio: Divide the current price by the 10-year average earnings to get the CAPE ratio.

Interpretation

The CAPE ratio helps in understanding the market’s valuation in a broader context compared to its historical earnings performance. Here’s a rough guide to interpret the CAPE ratio:

  1. High CAPE Ratio: Indicates that the market may be overvalued and could be headed for a potential downturn or correction. Historically, a CAPE ratio above 25 has often been a cautionary signal.

  2. Low CAPE Ratio: Suggests the market might be undervalued, potentially offering buying opportunities. Typically, a CAPE ratio below 15 is considered an indicator of undervaluation.

Historical Context

The CAPE ratio has been used to predict some of the significant market events:

Strengths of CAPE Ratio

  1. Long-Term Perspective: By averaging earnings over a decade, it smooths out short-term volatility and business cycle effects.

  2. Inflation Adjustment: Real earnings provide a clearer picture of true earning power over time.

  3. Historical Validity: CAPE has been a reliable indicator of market trends and potential reversals.

Limitations and Criticisms

  1. Backward-Looking: Critics argue that the CAPE ratio is inherently backward-looking and may not accurately reflect future market conditions or earnings potential.

  2. Structural Changes: Market dynamics and structures change over time. The CAPE ratio, based on historical data, might not account for these structural developments.

  3. Sector Composition Changes: Over time, the sector composition of market indices like the S&P 500 changes significantly. Comparing current CAPE ratios with historical ones might not be entirely apples-to-apples.

  4. Discount Rate: CAPE does not adjust for varying discount rates or changes in interest rates which can impact stock valuations significantly.

Practical Application

Investment Strategies

  1. Market Timing: Some investors use CAPE to guide their market entry and exit points, aiming to buy when the CAPE ratio is low and sell when it is high.

  2. Asset Allocation: CAPE ratio can also assist in tactical asset allocation by increasing exposure to equities when the CAPE ratio is low and reducing it when the ratio is high.

Case Study: Grantham, Mayo, & van Otterloo (GMO)

GMO, an investment management firm co-founded by Jeremy Grantham, is known for utilizing the CAPE ratio in its long-term investment strategy. They focus on achieving returns by taking advantage of market inefficiencies revealed by metrics like CAPE. For more information, you can visit GMO’s official website: GMO.

CAPE Ratio Across Different Markets

The CAPE ratio is not confined to the U.S. stock market. Investors and analysts apply it to various markets to gauge their relative valuations. For instance, the CAPE ratios for emerging markets, European markets, or specific country indices like Japan’s Nikkei 225 are also frequently scrutinized.

Modern Adaptations and Variants

CAPE Yield

One modern adaptation is the CAPE Yield, essentially the inverse of the CAPE ratio. It expresses the earnings yield of the market, making it comparable to bond yields.

[ \text{CAPE Yield} = \frac{1}{\text{CAPE Ratio}} ]

This provides a perspective on the expected long-term returns from equities compared to fixed-income assets.

Sector-Specific CAPE

Given the changing sectoral composition of markets, sector-specific CAPE ratios can provide more granular insights. Analysts calculate CAPE ratios for specific sectors like technology, healthcare, or finance to gauge relative sector valuations and identify potential investment opportunities.

Machine Learning and Big Data

In recent years, the integration of machine learning and big data analytics has allowed for more sophisticated modeling and forecasting using the CAPE ratio. Predictive models that consider a broader set of variables, including macroeconomic indicators, sentiment data, and global interconnectedness, enhance the predictive power of the CAPE ratio.

Conclusion

The CAPE ratio remains a valuable tool for investors and analysts, offering a long-term perspective on market valuation. While not without its limitations, its historical track record in predicting market trends, coupled with modern adaptations, continues to make it a relevant and widely-used metric. By understanding and interpreting the CAPE ratio, investors can make more informed decisions about market timing, asset allocation, and identifying potential investment opportunities.

For further reading and real-time CAPE ratio data, interested individuals can explore resources like Professor Robert Shiller’s official page or financial information providers like Bloomberg.

Links: