Negative Carry

“Negative carry” is a financial term that refers to a situation where the costs of holding a financial position or an asset exceed the income generated from that position. It is an important concept in both individual investing and institutional trading, as it can influence decision-making processes regarding portfolio management, asset allocation, and risk management.

Understanding Carry

In finance, “carry” refers to the cost or benefit of holding an investment or a financial position over time. This concept is widely applied across various financial instruments, including bonds, currencies, and derivatives. Carry can be positive or negative, depending on the relationship between the cost of holding the asset and the income it generates.

Positive Carry: This occurs when the income or returns generated from holding an asset exceed the costs associated with maintaining it. For example, if you hold a bond that pays a 5% annual interest rate, but the cost of borrowing money to buy the bond is only 3%, then the carry is positive because the income exceeds the cost.
Negative Carry: Conversely, negative carry arises when the costs of holding an asset exceed the income it generates. For instance, if you hold a bond that yields 2% interest while the cost of borrowing funds to buy the bond is 4%, you would be experiencing negative carry.

Components of Carry

Income Generated

The income generated from holding an investment varies based on the type of asset. It can include:

Interest payments: In the case of bonds and other fixed-income instruments, this refers to the periodic coupon payments received.
Dividends: For equity positions, this refers to the periodic dividends paid to shareholders.
Price appreciation: For assets such as stocks or real estate, this can also include any appreciation in the value of the asset over time.

Costs Incurred

The costs of holding a financial position can include:

Borrowing costs: If the asset is purchased using borrowed funds, the interest rate on the borrowed capital is a crucial factor.
Maintenance costs: This includes any fees or expenses associated with holding the asset, such as storage costs, management fees, or maintenance costs for physical assets.
Opportunity costs: This refers to the potential returns that could have been earned had the funds been allocated to a different investment.

Examples of Negative Carry

Carry Trades in Forex

In the foreign exchange (forex) market, a “carry trade” involves borrowing in a currency with a low interest rate and investing in a currency with a higher interest rate. The differential between the two interest rates is the “carry”. However, if the currency in which the investment is made depreciates significantly or if interest rate differentials change, the position can result in negative carry.

Example:

Borrowing in Japanese Yen (JPY) at a near-zero interest rate.
Investing in Australian Dollars (AUD) with a higher interest rate.
If the interest rate in Japan increases or the AUD depreciates, the cost of holding this position may exceed the returns, resulting in negative carry.

Holding Physical Commodities

Investing in physical commodities like gold or oil often involves costs beyond the purchase price. These can include storage costs, insurance, and transportation fees. If the price of the commodity does not appreciate sufficiently to cover these expenses, the position will result in a negative carry.

Implications of Negative Carry

Impact on Investment Returns

Negative carry can erode the overall returns of a portfolio, especially if the position with negative carry represents a significant portion of the investment. It introduces an additional layer of risk, as the investor must not only consider the potential for price appreciation but also manage the ongoing costs associated with the position.

Hedging Strategies

Investors and traders often face negative carry when they implement hedging strategies. For instance, purchasing options or other derivatives to protect against downside risk involves upfront costs (premiums) that may not be recovered if the anticipated adverse event does not materialize.

Impact on Yield Curve Strategies

Bond traders and fixed-income portfolio managers need to account for carry when developing yield curve strategies such as steepeners or flatteners. If the cost of financing long positions in bonds outweighs the income generated, the strategy may result in negative carry.

Risk Management Considerations

Monitoring Interest Rate Differentials

For forex carry trades, continuously monitoring interest rate differentials between the borrowed and invested currencies is crucial. Changes in monetary policy or economic conditions can rapidly alter these differentials, affecting the potential for negative carry.

Managing Leverage

Using leverage to enhance returns can amplify the effects of negative carry. Investors should carefully manage leverage ratios to ensure that the costs of borrowed funds do not offset the income generated by the investment.

Diversification

Diversifying the portfolio across different asset classes and investment strategies can help mitigate the risks associated with negative carry. By spreading investments across various holdings, the impact of negative carry on any single position is reduced.

Conclusion

Negative carry represents a significant consideration for investors and traders across various financial markets. It highlights the importance of understanding the ongoing costs associated with holding an investment and the necessity of balancing these costs against the potential returns. By carefully managing carry, incorporating risk management practices, and diversifying investment portfolios, market participants can better navigate the complexities of both positive and negative carry scenarios.

For further reading and resources on related topics, you may refer to:

Understanding negative carry and its implications allows for more informed decision-making and effective portfolio management, ensuring that costs do not unduly erode investment returns over time.